1366 Scuttle Hole Rd, Water Mill, NY 11976

An Exceptional Water Mill Retreat

In Water Mill, where pastoral landscapes and understated elegance define the setting, 1366 Scuttle Hole Road offers a refined expression of Hamptons living-private, beautifully composed, and designed for the way summers on the East End are meant to unfold. A classic gambrel silhouette and cedar-shingled façade establish the residence's timeless architectural character. Originally built in 2012 and comprehensively renovated in 2017, the home balances traditional Hamptons vernacular with a sophisticated, contemporary sensibility. Sunlight moves effortlessly through gracious interiors conceived for both intimate living and elegant entertaining, while a natural connection to the surrounding grounds brings the outdoors into nearly every aspect of the home. Approximately 4,600 square feet of above-grade living space is complemented by an expansive finished lower level, creating a residence of exceptional scale without sacrificing warmth or intimacy. Generously proportioned bedrooms provide private retreats for family and guests, while multiple living and entertaining spaces allow the house to transition seamlessly from quiet weekends to a full summer residence. Beyond the interiors, the property reveals itself as a private resort. Manicured lawns and mature landscaping create a secluded setting around the heated swimming pool, with generous outdoor spaces designed for long lunches, sunset cocktails and effortless summer entertaining. Most notably, the estate has just been elevated by the completion of a brand-new tennis and pickleball court, introducing an exceptional recreational amenity and completing the property's transformation into a true Hamptons compound. Days here have their own rhythm: morning coffee overlooking the grounds, afternoons alternating between the pool and the court, and evenings entertaining beneath the open sky. The location offers an equally compelling balance. Bridgehampton, Southampton, Sag Harbor and Water Mill are all within easy reach, placing celebrated restaurants, boutiques, farm stands, equestrian destinations and the Atlantic Ocean just minutes away-while at home, the property remains decidedly private. 1366 Scuttle Hole Road is more than a Hamptons residence. It is a beautifully realized private retreat-timeless in architecture, effortless in atmosphere, and newly complete with tennis and pickleball for an exceptional expression of summer living in Water Mill.