56 Carroll, Sag Harbor, NY 11963

Sag Harbor Jewel Box - Minutes to Village, Heated Saltwater Pool

A rare jewel box with a true mini-estate feel and exceptional privacy, moments from Sag Harbor Village. Renovated in 2026, this designer-owned farmhouse sits on a fully hedged half-acre with a heated saltwater pool, long gravel drive and turnkey Summer 2026 living. Set on a corner lot and approached via a private gravel driveway, the property unfolds as a secluded compound framed by mature hedges, custom cedar fencing, and layered landscaping of hydrangeas, wildflowers and established boxwoods. A separate service driveway accommodates additional vehicles, while the main entry and side mudroom entrance offer practical everyday flow. A 20' x 40' heated saltwater pool anchors multiple bluestone patio areas designed for lounging and dining. Professional landscape lighting enhances the grounds at night, reinforcing the rare sense of privacy this close to town. The European-inspired kitchen pairs warmth and craftsmanship with everyday function. Bas Stone Italian marble wraps the counters and full integrated sinks, complemented by custom cabinetry, a bespoke walnut pantry and coffee bar, an ILVE range and Miele appliances. Unlacquered brass fixtures and custom brass light switches sourced from the UK were selected to age gracefully over time. Four bedrooms and three full baths provide flexibility. The primary suite features Bas Stone marble, Waterworks unlacquered brass fixtures and herringbone white oak flooring. A main-level bedroom opens seamlessly to the pool terrace through double glass doors, creating effortless indoor-outdoor flow. Guest baths include Murano glass lighting from Italy, imported Italian marble and shower tile, and integrated marble sinks throughout. A newly created mudroom finished in hammered limestone from Morocco is ideal for pool days and summer living. Central air, Nest smart thermostats and a professionally installed ADT security system with perimeter cameras provide modern comfort and peace of mind. New infrastructure includes a GAF architectural roof, standing-seam metal porch roof, galvanized steel gutters, James Hardie siding and shingles, mahogany porches, bluestone patios and updated pool heating equipment. Private. Walkable. Fully renovated. Ready for Summer 2026 - simply bring your toothbrush. Also available fully furnished for a seamless, turnkey transition.